The U.S. Census Bureau is weighing a rule change that would limit the population count used to divide congressional seats to U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents. Local planners say the shift could complicate how Tampa Bay governments read their own data.
Ahead of the 2030 census, the bureau is considering new residency criteria that would exclude undocumented immigrants and certain legally present noncitizens from the apportionment count. Citizens and green card holders would remain in it.
The proposal is not final. The public comment period has been extended through Nov. 2.
The rules would also redefine “usual residence” as the place where a person lawfully spent the most days during the enumeration period, Jan. 3 through April 1.
What local planners are watching
Census data does more than set congressional seats. Local governments also use it to plan services and gauge community needs. In Hillsborough County, planners use census-based maps to find vulnerable populations and decide where to put services, including transportation for residents without cars.
Yassert Gonzalez, Plan Hillsborough’s manager of economics, demographics and research, said the data is widely relied upon. “Almost anywhere in the U.S., you can get some sort of census data,” he said.
His main worry is consistency. If populations once included in the total are now left out, he said, the numbers could diverge from what the county sees on the ground. “As a county government, we are taking care of the actual need, not what the census is saying,” Gonzalez said. He added that Washington’s picture of local conditions “will be less complete,” leaving counties “holding the bag for the unmet demands and unmet needs.”
Critics raise representation concerns
Adriel I. Cepeda Derieux, deputy director of the American Civil Liberties Union’s Voting Rights Project, argued the effects would reach beyond the people excluded. He pointed to mixed-status households, where citizen children live with noncitizen parents. The children would still be counted, but a state’s total could shrink.
“A policy that impacts one member of the household can impact everyone, including American citizens,” he said. He also said the bureau is proposing major changes “without studying their consequences.”
Federal money and enforcement
Census-derived data helped guide more than $2.8 trillion across 353 federal assistance programs in fiscal year 2021, according to a 2023 Census Bureau report. A George Washington University study found that inaccurate population data can affect funding distribution, though the impact depends on each program’s formula.
Separately, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development is reviewing immigration eligibility for federal housing aid. In January, HUD reported that nearly 200,000 tenants needed eligibility verification and that nearly 6,000 people had been identified as ineligible noncitizens.
HUD Secretary Scott Turner said enforcement is the agency’s job. “American taxpayer money, as pertains to HUD-funded housing, is for American people and American people only,” Turner said. “It’s my job to enforce the law, and that’s what I have done, and that’s what I will continue to do.”
HUD says the reviews are meant to protect taxpayer dollars and ensure assistance reaches eligible people.
The Census Bureau is accepting public comments on the proposal through Nov. 2.
Follow the St. Pete-Clearwater Sun on Facebook, Google, & X
St. Pete-Clearwater Sun: local St. Pete-Clearwater & Tampa Bay, FL news at PIE-Sun.com
