Suppose the structure value listed on the Property Appraiser’s website (or FEMA letter) does not meet FEMA requirements for repairing your property. Are there alternatives to getting a private appraisal? Yes, depending on your local regulations and policies, you may have other options. Here’s what you can consider:

1. Request a Re-evaluation: Some property appraiser offices allow property owners to request a reassessment or review of the structure’s valuation. Contact your local property appraiser’s office for guidance.
2. Consult Local Building Officials: Your local building department may accept alternative documentation, such as a contractor’s repair estimate, construction cost breakdown, or pre-damage valuation, to evaluate your situation.
3. Appeal FEMA Determinations: If the valuation affects your FEMA assistance eligibility, you may be able to appeal the determination by providing additional evidence, such as insurance valuations or documented repair costs.
4. Review Local Ordinances: Some municipalities may have specific provisions or exceptions related to FEMA’s 50% rule. Check with your local officials for details.

In any case, it’s a good idea to consult with a knowledgeable contractor, appraiser, or legal expert familiar with FEMA regulations to ensure you meet all requirements.

RELATED: FEMA Extends Deadline for Hurricane Aid Applications in Florida

New Option for Homeowners: Pre-Storm Building Value Reconsideration

Homeowners in Pinellas County, especially those in flood hazard areas, now have an additional option to address discrepancies in their property’s structure value needed for FEMA repair requirements. The Property Appraiser’s Office has introduced a Pre-Storm Building Value Reconsideration (BVR) process to help expedite recovery for many residents.

RELATED: What Is a Substantial Damage Determination Letter and Is It Necessary for a Permit to Make Hurricane-Related Repairs?

Addressing Structure Value Discrepancies

If the structure value indicated on the Property Appraiser’s website or FEMA letter is lower than what is needed to repair your property, homeowners can request a BVR. This process is particularly useful if updates or repairs have been made to the property that the appraiser’s office is unaware of, or if such work was completed between January 1 and the date of the storm. Learn more and request a BVR at Request BVR.

Applying for a BVR

To apply for a Pre-Storm Building Value Reconsideration, homeowners must provide:

• Photographic evidence of the property’s interior, dated pre-storm (original source, at least 1 MB in size).
• Contractor invoices for work done within the 24 months prior to the storm.
• Any other inspection reports or documents supporting the structure’s condition and quality before the storm damage.

Note: This service is currently unavailable for condominium properties, as the entire building must be valued.

RELATED: Does a Substantial Damage Determination Letter Automatically Qualify Me for a Permit to Make Hurricane-Related Repairs?

Process and Impact

Providing this documentation allows the Property Appraiser’s Office to make factual changes to the structure’s value, which will not affect 2024 taxes. Value estimates for 2025 will be based on the property’s condition as of January 1, 2025. If a factual change is justified, the office will issue an updated FEMA letter with a revised structure value and 50% calculation.

Understanding Value Differences

The structure value on the Property Appraiser’s FEMA letter is one of two methods allowed by FEMA to obtain the Actual Cash Value (ACV) of a structure. The Property Appraiser’s value estimate is primarily for tax assessment purposes and may differ from an independent ACV appraisal. Independent appraisals, performed by state-certified appraisers, include detailed inspections and owner-provided documentation, which may result in a higher structure value.

Additional Information

Homeowners have the right to hire an independent state-certified appraiser to conduct a retrospective ACV appraisal to present to their respective building department. For more details, a copy of Pinellas County’s Appraisal Review Checklist is available at Pinellas County Appraisals. Other jurisdictions may have their own review checklist.

RELATED: Can I Get a Permit Without a Substantial Damage Determination Letter if the Property’s Hurricane Repair Costs Don’t Exceed 50% of the Pre-Damage Value?

This new BVR process aims to provide homeowners with a more accurate valuation of their properties, facilitating necessary repairs and ensuring compliance with FEMA requirements.

Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, Google, & X

(Image credit: Google/Imagen 3)