After severe hurricanes like Helene and Milton, property owners across Florida are dealing with damaged homes, businesses, and properties. Among the many steps to rebuild, one crucial process is obtaining the required permits to begin repairs. For owners facing substantial damage—where the cost of repairs is estimated to be 50% or more of the property’s pre-damage value—a specific type of assessment is required, known as a Substantial Damage Determination Letter. However, for properties where repair costs are lower, owners often wonder if they can bypass this step and proceed directly with obtaining permits.

Next, we’ll break down how substantial damage determinations work, how they impact the permitting process, and how you may be able to proceed with repairs if your costs fall below the 50% threshold.

Understanding Substantial Damage Determination

What is Substantial Damage? 

Substantial damage is defined by FEMA and local building codes as damage where the cost of restoring the structure to its pre-damage condition is equal to or exceeds 50% of the structure’s market value before the damage occurred. This assessment is particularly significant in flood-prone areas as it’s a regulatory step tied to FEMA’s National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). 

READ: What Is a Substantial Damage Determination Letter and Is It Necessary for a Permit to Make Hurricane-Related Repairs?

Properties deemed substantially damaged are often required to comply with current floodplain management standards, which can mean raising the building elevation, enhancing structural supports, or even rebuilding to meet stricter codes.

What is a Substantial Damage Determination Letter? 

A Substantial Damage Determination Letter is a formal document issued by local authorities, typically based on inspections and assessments conducted by county or municipal officials, often with support from FEMA-approved contractors. This letter serves as a decision on whether a building has sustained substantial damage. If a property is deemed substantially damaged, the letter will outline the extent of compliance needed to meet the latest building standards.

The 50% Rule: What It Means for Permitting

Suppose repair costs for a damaged property are less than 50% of the property’s pre-damage market value. In that case, the property is generally not classified as “substantially damaged,” meaning that it may not need to meet the same extensive compliance standards. This is good news for property owners, as it often allows them to avoid the costs and delays associated with bringing the building up to the latest flood or structural standards.

READ: FEMA 50% Rule Already Catching Some Homeowners Completely Off Guard

Can You Get a Permit Without a Substantial Damage Determination Letter? 

The short answer: In many cases, yes. If you have documentation proving that your estimated repair costs are less than 50% of the pre-damage value, you may not need a Substantial Damage Determination Letter to proceed with permitting. However, local rules vary, so it’s essential to understand what specific requirements your county or city may impose.

How to Show That Repairs Are Less Than 50% of Pre-Damage Value

To move forward without a Substantial Damage Determination Letter, you’ll need to provide evidence that repair costs don’t exceed 50% of your property’s pre-damage value. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to document this:

1. Gather Evidence of Pre-Damage Property Value
   Obtain documentation that clearly shows the market value of the structure before the hurricane hit. This can include:
   • Recent property appraisals
   • County property assessment records
   • Real estate market analyses
2. Make sure to separate the building’s value from the land value, as only the building’s pre-damage value is relevant for this calculation.
3. Get Repair Cost Estimates
   Obtain a detailed estimate of the repair costs from a licensed contractor. The estimate should outline labor and material costs needed to return the property to its pre-damage condition.
4. Prepare a Damage Comparison Statement
   Some building departments may request a comparison statement that calculates the repair cost as a percentage of the pre-damage value. This shows clearly if repairs fall below the 50% threshold.
5. Submit Documentation with the Permit Application
   When you apply for a permit, include all your documentation—property value records, contractor estimates, and a statement showing your calculated percentage. This is usually sufficient for properties with minor to moderate damage.

Navigating Local Building Regulations

It’s essential to note that every county and city has its own permitting requirements. Here are a few examples of common local approaches:

• Pinellas County: In Pinellas County, officials allow property owners to submit permit applications if the owner provides documentation that repair costs are under 50% of the structure’s pre-damage value, even if they haven’t received a Substantial Damage Determination Letter.
• Hillsborough County: In some cases, Hillsborough County has issued guidance indicating that permits for repairs under the 50% threshold can proceed without waiting for a determination letter. However, they may require a formal application review to confirm compliance.
• Miami-Dade County: In areas with high flood risks, like Miami-Dade County, officials may impose stricter requirements even if repairs fall below 50%. In these cases, they may require inspections or additional certifications.

Check with your local building department to confirm the exact requirements for your area. The permitting authority can clarify if and when you may need additional paperwork or inspections, especially if your property is in a flood zone.

Special Circumstances: Mobile Homes and Older Structures

Permitting for mobile homes or structures with unique materials and designs can bring additional considerations. For example, mobile homes in flood-prone areas are typically subject to more rigorous inspection standards, and federal funds may not cover repairs in certain cases.

Older buildings that were “grandfathered in” under prior building codes may also need adjustments to meet modern standards. Owners of these properties may need to follow additional permitting steps to ensure structural safety and compliance, even if their repair costs fall below 50% of the pre-damage value.

Alternative Assistance Options

While FEMA grants may be unavailable for properties not deemed substantially damaged, some states or counties offer financial relief options for moderate damage repairs. Additional support may be available through local agencies and nonprofit organizations to help cover immediate repairs while waiting for final determinations.

Moving Forward with Repairs

If your property’s repair costs don’t exceed 50% of its pre-damage value, there’s a good chance you can obtain a permit without a Substantial Damage Determination Letter. The key to moving forward lies in gathering accurate documentation and understanding your local building department’s requirements. With detailed property value and repair cost estimates in hand, many property owners can begin the permitting process and make repairs without additional delays, getting one step closer to restoring their property and peace of mind after the storm.

Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, Google, & X

(Image credit: Shutterstock)