A proposed noise ordinance in St. Pete Beach is stirring strong opposition from residents and business owners who say it threatens the island’s vibrant nightlife and tourism-driven economy.

“If we had to stop live music, we’d pretty much go out of business,” said Matt Vario, owner of the Toasted Monkey. “We’re known for live music—it’s our bread and butter.”

In January, city commissioners voted 3-2 to keep discussions moving forward on the ordinance, citing numerous noise complaints from nearby residents. But in February, those in opposition packed a commission meeting, urging leaders to reconsider.

The current draft of the ordinance would impose strict “quiet hours” from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m., banning noise that can be heard more than 200 feet away from any business, bar, restaurant, or home. It would also prohibit sounds that exceed ambient noise levels by more than five decibels at neighboring properties.

“To shut everything down by seven is just… come on. It’s unreasonable,” said local resident Aaron Motta. “Most of these places don’t even get busy until after that. People here rely on those jobs to support their families.”

The proposal includes exceptions for emergencies, natural disasters, and city-approved events, according to officials.

“We still hope the commission realizes this isn’t what the broader community wants—it’s what a vocal minority wants,” Vario added. “Our job isn’t just to make rules. It’s to keep the beach alive and thriving.”

District 2 Commissioner Lisa Robinson told WFLA that the ordinance is being revised following significant public input earlier this year. The City of St. Pete Beach does not currently have a scheduled vote, and if adopted, it would be introduced as a pilot program subject to future adjustments.

Follow the St. Pete-Clearwater Sun on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, Google, & X

(Image credit: Patrick Heinzen)

PIE-Sun.com: local St. Pete-Clearwater news