Madeira Beach’s iconic John’s Pass Village and Boardwalk, known for its quaint turn-of-the-century charm and bustling tourist scene, might see significant changes in the near future. According to recent whispers and confirmed developments, a hotel project has been given the go-ahead by the city, potentially displacing six shops, while the popular Caddy’s restaurant faces an uncertain future due to the impacts of Hurricanes Helene and Milton.

Hotel Project at John’s Pass

Earlier this year, the city of Madeira Beach green-lit a significant development project proposed by a major Clearwater-based hotel developer. The project involves constructing a $25-30 million, six-story, 78-suite hotel complete with a 297-space parking garage. This public-private partnership aims to address the lack of hotel accommodations within John’s Pass Village, which has long been a point of discussion among local authorities and business owners. The proposed location for this development is on a vacant 2.8-acre parcel currently used as a parking lot, which would mean the displacement of at least six existing shops to make way for this new construction, according to previous reporting by the Tampa Bay Times.

The move has not been without controversy, with some city commissioners expressing reservations about the project. Concerns include the city’s control over the development, the impact on local businesses, and the preservation of the area’s unique character. However, proponents argue that the hotel could stimulate tourism and provide much-needed parking, potentially benefiting the local economy in the long run.

Caddy’s Restaurant’s Uncertain Future

On another somber note, Caddy’s restaurant, a beloved waterfront dining spot at John’s Pass, is facing significant challenges in reopening its doors. The back-to-back hurricanes, Helene and Milton, wreaked havoc across the Gulf Coast, with Madeira Beach taking a direct hit. Reports indicate that Caddy’s has sustained major damage, including the destruction of its tiki hut and other structural issues, leading to its current closure. The likelihood of Caddy’s reopening at John’s Pass seems slim as recovery efforts continue to be daunting, compounded by the financial and logistical implications of rebuilding in such a disaster-prone area, Patch reported.

Impact on Other Businesses

The hurricanes have not only put Caddy’s in jeopardy but have also affected many other businesses in John’s Pass. The area was described as “unrecognizable” post-Hurricane Helene, with debris, damaged structures, and flooded streets altering the landscape. While some businesses are in the process of recovery, the path back to normalcy is fraught with challenges. Many shops and restaurants are assessing whether they can financially and structurally rebuild or if it’s time to consider moving or closing permanently. The community spirit, however, remains strong, with local organizations and volunteers aiding in the cleanup and recovery efforts, per Fox 13 News Tampa Bay and WFLA.

Looking Ahead

The development of the hotel and the potential permanent closure of landmarks like Caddy’s signal a period of transition for John’s Pass. While development could bring new opportunities for tourism and economic growth, it also poses risks to the village’s distinctive cultural and historical ambiance. As Madeira Beach moves forward, balancing growth with preservation will be crucial. Local governance, business owners, and the community will need to navigate these changes carefully to ensure that John’s Pass retains its allure as one of Pinellas County’s top tourist attractions, even as it evolves.

As for Caddy’s, if it does not return to John’s Pass, it would mark the end of an era for many locals and tourists who have enjoyed its waterfront views and culinary offerings. The future of John’s Pass, with or without Caddy’s, will continue to be a topic of keen interest and debate in the community.

Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, Google, & X

(Image credit: John’s Pass on Instagram)